$\begingroup$

Fifty minutes ago it was four times as many minutes past three o'clock. How many minutes is it to six o'clock..?

I have got the solution online but have doubts in it : 

There are 180 minutes between 3 o'clock and 6 o'clock. Call x the number of minutes to 6 o'clock. Then it is 180 - x minutes past 3 o'clock and 50 minutes ago it was 130 - x minuted past 3 o'clock. Using the 4 times as many minutes past three o'clock bit we can form the equation 130 - x = 4x and solve it 130 = 5x x = 26 so yes it is 26 minutes.

According to me :

How it is 4x in above equation , it should be 4(180-x) , and new equation should be 130-x = 4(180-x) , because it says that it was 4 times as many minutes past 3:00 PM.

please explain. according to the solution if it is 4x on the RHS of the equation , then according to me the question is wrong , and should be written as : 

Fifty minutes ago it was four times as many minutes to 6 o'clock.
$\endgroup$0

3 Answers

$\begingroup$

The figure below may help explain (apologies for the sub-optimal formatting)

enter image description here

$\endgroup$4$\begingroup$

I think the question means $4$ times as many minutes to $6$ o' clock from now.

$\endgroup$2$\begingroup$

a little correction

it says

Fifty minutes ago it was four times as many minutes past three o'clock

IT means X

WAS means =

FOUR TIMES means 4 *

AS MANY MINS PAST 3 means 130-X

so equation becomes X=4*(130-X); X=104 mins

How many mins past 3 = 130-X=130-104= 26mins

example If a Father's age is 2 times the age of Son and Son's age is 30yrs. then the equation will be X = 2*30; X = 60yrs. Not 2X = 30; X = 15yrs.

Hope this explains the above question.

$\endgroup$